Don’t pay for what you don’t use in libCVD

libCVD has a pretty spiffy image loading function. You can do:

Image<Rgb<byte>> img = img_load("a_file.ext");

and you’re ready to go accessing pixels. The img_load function takes care of a lot for you: it determines the file type, calls the appropriate handler, then converts whatever the pixel type on disk is (it could be binary, greyscale or high bit depth) into the type in your program (and you don’t even need to provide the type to img_load).

At this point bear in mind that libCVD is a library for computer vision (especially frame rate vision), and at that point you know which type you need at compile time. The automatic conversion would be a showstopper if you wanted to accurately represent the file, but for the domain, you want to get the data into the desired type.

This function is very easy to use, but potentially expensive because libCVD supports quite a wide variety of image types. That causes two problems for shipped code:

  1. The shipped binary will be larger than necessary because it will contain code to load image formats you probably don’t care to support in production (e.g. FITS).
  2. Increased attack surface. TIFF in particular is a very complex file format with a vast number of options, and as a result libtiff has even recently had a number of serious CVEs

You can compile libCVD without an external library (e.g. TIFF), but currently there’s no way of switching off built-in libraries. I could add that, but that creates another problem: I didn’t add those formats for no reason. During debugging or analysis it can often be very useful to save and load internal state such as floating point images (for which you’d need TIFF or FITS). Then you’d need to build libCVD in multiple configurations, both with and without various options and switch them in and out as necessary.

That’s a big administrative disadvantage and adds a continual ongoing burden of wrangling multiple build configurations. The solution it turns out was remarkably simple:

Why not provide a type list? Then the linker can remove unused code.

– David McCabe

And that’s it, really! There are three minor variations:

Image<byte> i = img_load("file"); 
Image<byte> i = img_load<PNG::Reader, JPEG::Reader>("file"); 

using Files = std::tuple<PNG::Reader, JPEG::Reader>;
Image<byte> i = img_load<Files>("file");  

The first works as always and will load all supported image types. The second and third limit the list to only the specified ones and other types won’t be included anywhere in the resulting binary. Both variations are provided for ergonomics. The second because it’s nice to use directly, the third because you can’t save a parameter pack.

Internally it’s implemented using tuples because converting from a pack to a tuple is easy, but the reverse is more annoying.

The implementation is pretty straightforward (edited for brevity; the runtime error checking stuff isn’t relevant). First the code to load given a typelist in a tuple:

template<class I, class ImageTypeList, int N=0>
void img_load_tuple(Image<I>& im, std::istream& i, [[maybe_unused]] int c){
	if constexpr (N==std::tuple_size_v<ImageTypeList>) {
		throw Exceptions::Image_IO::UnsupportedImageType();
		using ImageReader = std::tuple_element_t<N, ImageTypeList>;
			CVD::Internal::readImage<I,ImageReader>(im, i);
			img_load_tuple<I, ImageTypeList, N+1>(im, i, c);

It’s a pretty run-of-the-mill compile time iteration scheme, which is now just a single fnuction with if constexpr. Note that loading makes it’s decision based on the first byte of the file, and each image loader has a function to test for a match. This replaces the old if-else chain which I misremembered as a switch statement (edited):

	template<class I> void img_load(Image<I>& im, std::istream& i)
	  unsigned char c = i.peek();
	  if(c == 'P')
	    CVD::Internal::readImage<I, PNM::Reader>(im, i);
	  else if(c == 0xff)
	    CVD::Internal::readImage<I, JPEG::reader>(im, i);
	  else if(c == 'I' || c == 'M') //Little or big endian TIFF
	    CVD::Internal::readImage<I, TIFF::tiff_reader>(im, i);
	  else if(c == 0x89)
	    CVD::Internal::readImage<I, PNG::png_reader>(im, i);
	  else if(c == 'B')
	    CVD::Internal::readImage<I, BMP::Reader>(im, i);
	  else if(c == 'S')
	    CVD::Internal::readImage<I, FITS::reader>(im, i);
	  else if(c == 'C')
		CVD::Internal::readImage<I, CVDimage::reader>(im, i);
	  else if(c == ' ' || c == '\t' || isdigit(c) || c == '-' || c == '+')
	    CVD::Internal::readImage<I, TEXT::reader>(im, i);
	    throw Exceptions::Image_IO::UnsupportedImageType();

Fortunately the image types are distinguishable from exactly 1 byte. This is handy because it allows all applicable types to be read from a non-seekable istream (e.g. one wrapping a pipe) without any modification because you can peek exactly one byte.

The neat bit allowing the dual interfaces easily is a template which turns its input into a tuple. You give it a tuple or a parameter pack and you always get a tuple back:

template<class... T> struct as_tuple{
	using type = std::tuple<T...>;

template<class... T> struct as_tuple<std::tuple<T...>>{
	using type = std::tuple<T...>;

This allows then a single function which has no opinions on what it is meant to operate on:

template <class I, class Head = Internal::AllImageTypes, class... ImageTypes>
void img_load(Image<I>& im, std::istream& i)
	img_load_tuple<I, typename Internal::as_tuple<Head, ImageTypes...>::type>(im, i, c);

The only flourish is taking two arguments for the loaders, one simple one a pack in order to allow the arguments to be defaulted.

The results I think gives the best of all worlds. It has a simple to use interface for the library, allows the user to not pay for what they don’t use, avoids compile time configuration, and it’s a clear and straightforward implementation. It also enforces a more sensible separation: the image loaders themselves can determine from the file magic bytes whether they can operate, rather than separating two different parts of the loading into different places.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s